CSFF Blog Tour Book Review: Captives

By: Thomas F. Booher

Review: 3.5 out of 5 stars.

When I review books, I have a scale in my mind, and various criteria that go into it. I keep mental notes, and sometimes write them in the margins on each page. Shortly before the halfway point of this book, I was ready to give up on it. The story moved too fast to grasp it or get a feel for the many characters. Attempting to do so felt like watching a car fly down the highway as you sit from your porch. By the time you locked onto something, the scene or characters shifted. Beyond that, the lame "cursings" uttered by Jordan drove me crazy. Worse, I didn't think Omar's (and some of the other characters') actions and reactions early in the story were true to life, which put me off.

I'll detail those concerns in subsequent posts, but I want to say that the second half of the book was vastly improved. It was almost like Jill Williamson vaped some grass, and a ten at that. The story slowed a bit, enough to catch its details and the intricacies of the characters. The Safe Lands are a fresh and fascinating place. Best of all, the moral dilemmas were, at times, realistic and palpable. This is due largely to the characters acting more true to life to the situations they were put in (certainly compared to their response to losing their family members at Glenrock).

Williamson captures the appeal of the Safe Land's alluring sins in a powerful way, and this, I think, is where we see the potential of so called "Christian" fiction writing . The most poignant parts of the story deal with the issue of forced surrogacy and the separation the mothers experience as their babies are whisked away from them, sometimes before they even get to see them. The Safe Land's total rejection of the family unit stands in contradistinction to the villagers of Glenrock's way of life. This is fascinating to see play out (and strikes close to home as my wife and I will have our first child in about a month), and has me more intrigued than anything else to read the next book in the series. I will talk more about this in my next post.

There are other questions and concerns I have, some of which the author raises with ten discussion questions at the end of the book, some of which the author does not raise. Young teenagers will most enjoy this book and most profit from thinking through the mucky morality of the characters. The discussion questions should help facilitate the process of thinking these things through, and hopefully my discussion in my following posts will as well.

In conjunction with the CSFF Blog Tour, I received a free copy of this book from the publisher.

Captives can be purchased here - http://www.amazon.com/Captives-Safe-Lands-Jill-Williamson/dp/0310724228/

Author’s website - http://www.jillwilliamson.com/

Check out other reviews of Captives for the CSFF blog tour:

Why Pastors Shouldn't Preach In Jeans (Especially Skinny Jeans)

By: Thomas F. Booher I can't think of a better way to get labeled a legalist than to title a post like this. Hopefully by the end you will not see this as legalism and will see this as what it is- my attempt at describing what I believe is proper ecclesiology as defined by God in Scripture. So then, what is church? What does Scripture say we should be doing and not doing on Sunday mornings? That's what I want to explore. The Bible says to gather together in Christ's name; to teach, encourage, and admonish one another; to sing psalms and hymns and spiritual songs with thankfulness in our hearts to God (Heb. 10:24-25; Mat. 18:20; Col. 3:16). There are to be deacons (Acts 6:1-6) and elders (Ti. 1:5) in the church who act as overseers, and in the case of elders, are the shepherds of the flock who teach the word and rebuke with authority (Ti. 1:9). God must call one to be a pastor/elder (Eph. 4:11). As such those who are called by God to preach the word are held to a ...

The Stone Choir/Corey Mahler Invert God's Revelation

https://coreyjmahler.com/the-european-peoples-and-christianity/ *****EDIT: Some have said that they, or at least Corey Mahler perhaps believes, that the European religions were deviations from Christianity, believed by Noah and his sons. Over time, sinful man and demons twisted these European religions, which I think their argument is that it was originally Christian/derived from Noah and his offspring. Nordic paganism had the most in common with Christianity, even with Odin sacrificing himself on a tree, and therefore the Europeans were the most ripe and ready to embrace Christianity and continue to advance the cause of Christ more than other peoples/races/nations over the last 2,000 years since Christ. To that I simply say, I appreciate the context given, but even if all that were true (maybe it is, maybe it is not), it doesn't change the fundamental points of my post below. Syncretism, Odinism, etc., even if it was somehow a distorted derivation flowing from the true...

Some Problems in the PCA (Presbyterian Church in America)

By: Thomas F. Booher NOTE: I posted what's below to Facebook on this day, December 6, 2016. I wanted to post this here for record keeping and so that it can have a more visible and permanent viewership for those concerned or wishing to be more informed about the PCA. I would like to explain my love for and grave concerns within the PCA (Presbyterian Church in America), the denomination in which I am currently a member and have served as a ruling elder. The state of the PCA is, in my estimation, not a consistently conservative, orthodox, and confessional one. I believe it is in the midst of much compromise, and I do not think that the average lay person is aware of it. It grieves me to say these things. I wish they were not true. I grew up in the PCA, and until several years ago I was still under the delusion that all was well in this denomination, that it was, by and large, holding fast to the Word of God. I still believe that there are many...

The Tulip Driven Life

Search This Blog